I agree with some, not w/ others
My bottom 10
No particular order
Top 10 no particular order
I also never played waw so that explains that
@OP: The main (unstated) thing I got from your list (which was nicely done btw) was this: People tend to hate maps that superficially "look like" they cater to a particular playstyle, but, in reality, deliver better results with a different (often counter-intuitive) playstyle.
For example: Downturn, Array, Outpost -- these are GREAT shotgun/SMG maps that cater to rushing/flanking (so long as you have a good idea how the spawns work and how traffic flows); yet people try to play them as sniper/AR maps, leading to frustration & loathing when a more reserved playstyle means seldom seeing an enemy.
Of course, some maps just legitimately suck (Estate, I'm looking @ you.)
Your sort of right. This list wasnt made by me, it was from hundreds of votes. But in terms of the reasons why i said each map was bad, yeah domination and team deathmatch are pretty much the only game modes im referring to. Since those are mostly the only two game modes i play, thats what i had to base the reasoning off of
Why then thankyou ! Yes that os typically true. I can agree with that , of course different maps are better with different gametypes. Eg ; skidrow: horrible in ffa, td . Amazing in demo, search and dominationh . Same with say village. I hatttteee it in TD but loove it in domination . And im a big domination fan. So all these maps apply more to this.
And yes; i totally agree with you. We think alike. I like your counter to my list :) xbox or ps3?