Ghosts General Discussion

Re: Sound issue

in reply to dtuchpunk

But then someone is around to hear it...

ghosthound
Likes: 277
Posts: 12833
Highlighted

Re: Sound issue

in reply to ghosthound


Here. So it depens what "sound" is

Roll the dice. Life is a gamble
GRaS is OP. SaND get's everywhere
dtuchpunk Level 75
Likes: 2332
Posts: 9813

Re: Sound issue

in reply to ghosthound

How does it exist if there's no-one to perceive it?

You set the answer with the question, it exists, so it makes a noise.

A more profound question would be, is it possible to prove that it always will make a noise if no-one or nothing is there to hear/record it?

RobbieRocket
Likes: 662
Posts: 3682

Re: Sound issue

in reply to RobbieRocket

The more profound answer is, yes, it would.

Because when you look up at the stars at night? The light you see from them happened in the past, often millions of years ago when no one was there to see/hear/ or record it. Likewise, the sound happened.

"At the end of the match, there remains only ... nuttin 2 say."
nuttin2say
Likes: 3511
Posts: 6289

Re: Sound issue

in reply to ghosthound

Is it just me or is every response to this question marked with a correct answer?

ghosthound
Likes: 277
Posts: 12833

Re: Sound issue

in reply to ghosthound

Don't see it. I got 3 answer correct in once in the port question from maccabi

Roll the dice. Life is a gamble
GRaS is OP. SaND get's everywhere
dtuchpunk Level 75
Likes: 2332
Posts: 9813

Re: Sound issue

in reply to dtuchpunk

dtuchpunk wrote:



Don't see it. I got 3 answer correct in once in the port question from maccabi


you know the forums are buggy

Maccabi Level 75
Likes: 4408
Posts: 15953

Re: Sound issue

in reply to dtuchpunk

Doh

I think it may be because I asked the question and I then have to mark one as correct.

ghosthound
Likes: 277
Posts: 12833

Re: Sound issue

in reply to ghosthound

ghosthound wrote:



If a tree falls in the woods and nobody is around to hear it, does it make a sound?


only if you watch the playback in theatre oh wait we dont have theatre any more .

trees falling make a sound on current gens but will not on xbox one due to the fact ms decided to make sure noones headsets work till 2014

Maccabi Level 75
Likes: 4408
Posts: 15953

Re: Sound issue

in reply to ghosthound
Solution

Hey everyone,

I appreciate everyone's eagerness to answer ghosthound's philosophic question. However, I am moving this thread to "General" since this is not a support question for Ghosts.

Cheers!

^MC

ATVI Support

Community Coordinator
Likes: 548
Posts: 3161

Studios