I have both PS4 and an XBOX1 with WW2 for both. I have had TONS of problems with the PS4 playing or should I say not playing because of constant errors but the XBOX1 has gave me very little problems. I think buying it for PS4 was a big mistake!!!
I not buying the OP post, the vast majority of issues have been xbox related according to posters around here.
There is no question there are players having issues on the One since the Winter Siege update as we've seen on the forums but I'm pretty sure it's just a minority. I've had very few disconnects and have played a lot since the update with and against a lot of other players.
I play on both and the empirical evidence I have experienced first hand is that the XBONE is most problematic. Although, not that many problems even on that system. I seem to be the biggest problem in my matches, lol.
I play on Xbox and enough isseus.
Biggest one incostitant connection.
And being stuck for long in loading screens.
When playing in party buddy will back in lobby and I will still be stuck in score screen.
I can only speak for Xbox but EVERYDAY I have to pull the plug and reboot for the game to actually search for a game. When it first loads HQ is derted and I know then I need to pull the plug and start again. Most connections to a game are lost before it loads except for the Carentan HC moshpit.
Noticed also after about 3 minutes of first round of HC DOM I start skipping and then get wasted a lot easier than before that skipping episode every game.
The past few days my 2013 Xbox has failed to recognise the external HDD I have this stored on so I have to switch USB inputs just to get the thing to load but I guess that's my machine getting "old" despite my faithful 360 arcade lasting 2005 - 2013 RIP.